Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. When you buy through Amazon links or other links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.

Best Colombian Coffee K-Cups for Keurigs – Top 10 Options

Best Colombian Coffee K Cups for Keurigs

Colombian coffee is famous for its luxurious and sweet-tasting flavors that make it palatable to drink plain. You’ll find it in many coffee shops around the country.

But you don’t necessarily need to make it to a coffee shop to enjoy this delicious blend. If you have a Keurig, there are plenty of Colombian coffee K-Cups for you to try.

Not sure which ones to get first? We’ve compiled this list of the best Colombian coffee K-Cups for Keurigs to help you get started.

Best Colombian Coffee K-Cups for Keurigs

Victor Allen’s 100% Colombian Coffee K-Cups

Victor Allen's Coffee 100% Colombian, Medium Roast, 80 Count, Single Serve Coffee Pods for Keurig K-Cup Brewers

If you’re looking for something that’s Kosher, you won’t need to look any further than these Victor Allen’s K-Cups. They’ve been certified as Kosher by the Orthodox Union.

Even if that doesn’t matter to you, there are plenty of reasons to choose these K-Cups. For starters, they tend to be very affordable for the amount you get.

Additionally, even though the coffee itself comes from Colombia, it’s blended and roasted right here in the USA.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: Keurig 2.0 Brewers
  • Number of K-Cups: 42, 80, or 120
  • Roast: Medium
  • Caffeinated: Yes
  • GMO-Free: Victor Allen’s K-Cups are all GMO-free, making them perfect for people trying to avoid GMOs.
  • Kosher-Friendly: If you need Kosher food for religious or dietary reasons, you can have these K-Cups guilt-free.

Read Also: What is Colombian Coffee? 

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 12 Count (Pack of 6) - Packaging May Vary

Green Mountain has tons of K-Cup varieties, including these Colombian ones. The taste of these K-Cups is caramelly and chocolatey, giving your morning cup of coffee a deeply satisfying flavor.

We also like the guilt-free aspect of these cups. Green Mountain sources their coffee sustainably, setting themselves apart from many competitors.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: All Keurig Brewers
  • Number of K-Cups: 12 or 96
  • Roast: Medium
  • Caffeinated: Yes
  • Sustainability: Green Mountain has pledged to sustainably source all their coffee by the end of 2020, so you can feel good about choosing these K-Cups.
  • Decadent Taste: The sweet, chocolatey flavor of these cups is a legitimate pleasure to drink.

Folgers 100% Colombian Medium Roast Coffee, 96 Keurig K-Cup Pods

You could reasonably call Folgers the king of budget-friendly coffee. This affordable bundle can provide you up to 128 K-Cups, which is likely to last you for months.

Plus, if you decide you’re ready to try something else, you can get other types of roasts from them. There’s plenty to try to keep your taste buds thrilled for a long time to come.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: All Keurig Brewers.
  • Number of K-Cups: 72, 96, & 128.
  • Roast: Medium
  • Caffeinated: Yes
  • Recyclable: Do you hate the waste of K-Cups? You’ll be happy to know that these Folgers cups are completely recyclable, allowing you to reduce your waste.

Amazon Brand - Solimo Medium Roast Coffee Pods, Colombian, Compatible with Keurig 2.0 K-Cup Brewers, 100 Count

One thing Amazon excels at is offering their own brands as inexpensive alternatives to popular name brands. Solimo is one such example of an economical option when it comes to K-Cups.

The reduced cost doesn’t mean you’re necessarily sacrificing flavor, either. These cups are made completely from Colombian coffee, known for their delicate and floral taste.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: 1.0 and 2.0 Keurig Brewers.
  • Number of K-Cups: 24 or 100.
  • Roast: Medium
  • Caffeinated: Yes
  • Various Combos: These K-Cups are sold in multiple different combinations, allowing you to get more than just Colombian coffee in a box.

Gevalia Colombia K-Cup Coffee Pods, for a Keto and Low Carb Lifestyle (84 ct Box)

Have you ever had a cup of coffee that was disgustingly bitter? That’s something you won’t need to worry about with these Gevalia Colombia Medium Roast K-Cup Pods.

Instead, what you can look forward to is a deep, rich, and lively flavor that will help perk you up first thing in the morning. You won’t find yourself wanting to dump out your coffee mug when you brew with these cups.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: 1.0 and 2.0 Keurig Brewers.
  • Number of K-Cups: 72, 84, or 100.
  • Roast: Medium.
  • Caffeinated: Yes
  • Kosher: These K-Cups are suitable for Kosher diets.

Read Also: Keurig K-Mini vs K15

Starbucks Medium Roast K-Cup Coffee Pods — Colombia for Keurig Brewers — 6 boxes (60 pods total)

We’ve all had cups of coffee that made us want to gag or spit when we sipped on them. Fortunately, that won’t be the case with these Starbucks Medium Roast Colombia K-Cup Coffee Pods.

The flavor is designed to be incredibly smooth, going down easily with each sip. In addition to the floral notes you can often detect in Colombian coffee, you’ll find there’s a low nuttiness here, too, as an extra pleasing hint.

This is a great pick for fans of the international coffee chain. With these K-Cups, you can continue to enjoy your favorite coffee right at home.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: All Keurig brewers.
  • Number of K-Cups: 10 or 60.
  • Roast: Medium.
  • Caffeinated: Yes.
  • Smooth Flavor: Lacking the bitterness of other coffees, these K-Cups will go down smoothly each time you brew them.
  • Recyclable: To cut down on waste, you can recycle each of these K-Cups after brewing.

Eight O'Clock Coffee Colombian Peaks Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee Pods, 24 Count (Pack of 4)

These Eight O’Clock K-Cups allow you to truly sample the gourmet with every beverage. The beans this company uses all come from high-altitude locations in Colombia, leading to a well-rounded and sweet flavor you won’t be able to get enough of.

As a bonus, these K-Cups are also all Kosher. This means they are perfectly suitable for anyone adhering to a Kosher diet.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: All Keurig brewers.
  • Number of K-Cups: 48, 72, or 96.
  • Roast: Medium.
  • Caffeinated: Yes
  • Certified Kosher: If you’re adhering to a Kosher diet, you can safely drink these cups, as they’ve been certified Kosher by the Orthodox Union.

Maud's Organic Colombian Coffee (Organic Medium Roast Coffee), 24ct. Solar Energy Produced Recyclable Single Serve Fair Trade Single Origin Organic Coffee Pods - 100% Arabica Coffee, KCup Compatible

Many people overlook everything that goes into the products we get to enjoy on a daily basis. You might be surprised to learn about the trade practices involved in everything you buy.

That’s why we like Maud’s Organic Colombian Coffee so much. It’s never a purchase you’ll feel guilty for, because the coffee used in these K-Cups is fair trade, meaning everyone involved in the process was fairly compensated for their efforts.

Furthermore, you can feel confident about any environmental concerns with these K-Cups. They’re organic and recyclable, making the company’s slogan – saving the world one cup at a time – especially fitting.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: 2.0 Keurig Brewers.
  • Number of K-Cups: 24
  • Roast: Medium
  • Caffeinated: Yes
  • Fair Trade: You can feel good about purchasing these K-Cups, knowing that they’re fair trade.
  • Organic: Since the K-Cups are organic, you get the peace of mind of knowing that they’re all-natural and GMO-free.
  • Recyclable: These cups won’t fill up your garbage can, as they’re completely recyclable.

Read Also: Keurig K-Supreme vs Mini

Folgers 100% Colombian Decaf Medium Roast Coffee, 72 Keurig K-Cup Pods

A lot of people joke about decaf coffee, but there’s no denying that there’s a time and a place for it. You don’t necessarily want to have a fully caffeinated drink in the evening while you unwind, for example.

If you want a drink that won’t jolt you with caffeine, then rest assured you can still enjoy the caramelly nuttiness of Colombian coffee. With these Folgers K-Cups, you can sip on your Colombian coffee whenever you like without the side effect of being kept wide awake into the night.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: All Keurig brewers.
  • Number of K-Cups: 72 or 96.
  • Roast: Medium.
  • Caffeinated: No.
  • Recyclable: All these K-Cups are totally recyclable, allowing you to reduce your waste.

Community Coffee 100% Colombia 36 Count Coffee Pods, Medium Dark Roast, Compatible with Keurig 2.0 K-Cup Brewers

You’ve likely noticed that many of the K-Cups on this list are medium roast. This is because Colombian coffee, which typically tastes wonderful straight, is best preserved when it’s a lighter or medium roast.

But some people simply prefer the smokiness of a dark roast. For that reason, we had to include these Community Coffee K-Cups on our list. They were one of the few options we could find which weren’t a medium roast.

Beyond the roast, there’s much to love about these cups. For one thing, we like how they’re quality tested, so you can be sure that each drink is as good as the last.

  • Compatible Keurig Brewers: 2.0 Keurig brewers.
  • Number of K-Cups: 36 or 72.
  • Roast: Medium-dark.
  • Caffeinated: Yes.
  • Quality Tested: All the beans are scored, ensuring that the taste and aroma are up to par.

Choosing the Best Colombian Coffee K-Cups


Every coffee bean that goes into your drinks is roasted prior to brewing. As the beans roast, they take on steadily darker colors, hence the names light, medium, and dark roast.

Generally, Colombian coffee is best as a light or medium roast. There are a couple reasons for this: preserving the nutty and sweet flavors of the Colombian beans and preserving the caffeine. The longer you roast a coffee bean, the more caffeine it loses and the original flavor is covered.

However, some people prefer dark roasts for their flavor. Dark roasts tend to be less acidic with a marked bitterness and smokiness that some just can’t get enough of.

In short, grab light or medium roast Colombian K-Cups if you want a sweeter experience. If you want something deeper and more bitter, however, get dark roast K-Cups.

Read Also: Top 6 Best Home Coffee Roasters for Dark Roast

Brewer Compatibility

Keurigs have been around for years. As new models come out, updates are made and K-Cups are created to be compatible with those new models.

For that reason, it’s important to determine which Keurig models a K-Cup is compatible with before you buy it. K-Cups can get fairly expensive – you wouldn’t want to buy a bunch, only to discover that they were incompatible with your Keurig.

Start by confirming the Keurig model you have. You can use this guide to determine if your Keurig is a 1.0 or 2.0 model. 

Number of Servings

You should also pay attention to just how many K-Cups you’re getting in a particular box. Usually, you can find this information in the name of the product or right up near the top of the listing.

As for how many you want, think about how often you’ll be drinking coffee. Not only that, but will you be sharing these K-Cups with other people? If you drink multiple cups a day or share your Keurig with friends and family, you’ll want to get more K-Cups.

On the other hand, if you’re only drinking one cup of a coffee a day, there’s no reason for you to get a huge bundle of them if you don’t want to.

Wrap Up

Our goal in this post was to provide you a wide sampling of Colombian coffee K-Cups for your Keurig. As you can see from this list, however, there are tons of options out there, and it can be a little difficult to settle on just one.

If you asked us which one to try first, we’d suggest Maud’s Organic Colombian Coffee. Not only do we think the organic coffee beans will give you a memorable flavor, but we liked the peace of mind you’ll get from knowing they’re fair trade.

Leave a Comment